The Life of a Disney Child: Are Disney Movies Good or Bad for Children?

Are you one of the children that has grown up with all of the Disney movies?

Is it hard to just pick one of your favorites?

Do you randomly find yourself singing a Disney song in your head?

Walt Disney has made a huge impact on the lives of children in multiple generations and is still making an impact on adults as well. Countless movies have been produced to serve different life lessons and morals for the audience to take away with them. Since Disney movies have such a huge impact on children of all ages, why is there a crowd that is so against them and think that they convey the wrong message to children?

This topic really interested me because I was and still am a Disney fan. The movies definitely have made a huge impact on my life, but not in a bad way. Yes I always wanted to become a Disney Princess and pretend that a prince was going to come my rescue, but I knew that there is a difference between the movies and real life.

 

Multiple people believe that Walt Disney is racist and sexist. They believe that only white people are represented by Disney and that the women in the movies are seen as the typical “damsel in distress.”

The typical princess is usually described as being tall, thin, pale skin, and long hair. Yes, this is the case for many of the early Disney princesses, such as Aurora, Snow White, and Belle. Few think that this messes with girls’ minds saying if they don’t look like the stereotypical princess, they aren’t beautiful. Often these pessimists forget about the Disney movies that don’t involve a princess that is white. Mulan, Pocahontas, Jasmine from Aladdin, Tianna of Notre Dame are just a few of the movies that involve people of different ethnic backgrounds. Everyone is represented, so there isn’t a need to feel that Disney gravitates to only one ethnic background.

There are some racism examples that people have found in several Disney movies that just aren’t princess-related. Here are a few: (more can be found here)

In Aladdin, in the intro son “Arabian Nights,” which first contained the lyrics “Where they cut off your ear / If they don’t like your face / It’s barbaric, but hey, it’s home.” When it was released on DVD though, the lyrics were changed to “Where it’s flat and immense and the heat is intense.”

Another example is Sebastian in The Little Mermaid being portrayed as a Jamaican saying it’s better under the sea because you don’t have to get a job.

There are also the monkeys in The Jungle Book that are supposedly “African American sounding” while the other characters sound British. The monkeys are also singing about wanting to be human, which is symbolic for African Americans wanting to be humans and not slaves or under everyone else.

I have seen all of these disney movies and I never picked up on any of these assumptions and there are even adults that don’t even notice. I feel that people like to analyze everything just to find something wrong. The pessimists are making nothing into such a big deal.

Some consider Disney movies sexist because the princess is usually in some type of trouble, is considered weak, and needs a man to save her in the end. The most referenced example is the movie Sleeping Beauty. She pricks her finger on the spinning and is put to sleep. The only way that she can be saved is to be kissed by a prince. People think that this shows little girls that they are incapable of accomplishing anything on their own. Another example is Belle from Beauty and the Beast. The negative thinking audience believes that Belle is in an abusive relationship with the Beast and there is nothing she can do about it. Once Belle is set free to take care of her father, she returns very quickly, which is what most victims of abuse do. People also think that there is sexism in the Little Mermaid with Ariel. Ariel changes her physical appearance just to be with the man she loves. By sacrificing her voice and signing Ursula’s contract, she is representing women’s sacrifice of their voice and opinions for the happiness of the man in their lives. Yes these are very sexist (along with others) but there are more movies where the woman is the hero in the end.

In Mulan, she ends up pretending to be a man to take her father’s spot in the Chinese army. She goes through the training, but once people find out she is female, she is sent home. A problem then occurs and Mulan ends up saving her country fighting, being more successful and determined than the men in the army. Disney’s newest movie, Frozen, most definitely breaks all of the stereotypes that people make about Disney movies. Queen Elsa has a magical power that is hard for her to control. Her powers get out of hand and she ends up leaving the castle. Her sister, Princess Anna is then in charge. Instead of having the men go after Elsa, Anna goes after her herself. While talking to Queen Elsa, Princess Anna gets struck by Elsa’s powers and is told that the only way to be saved is by an act of true love. Princess Anna falls for Prince Hans and she falls under his spell that she is in love with him and is going to marry him after only knowing him for a day. Towards the end of the movie we find out that Prince Hans was fake and never really loved Anna, he jut wanted to rule the kingdom. Since Prince Hans never loved Anna, she isn’t sure if she will be saved. Princess Anna then proceeds to freeze and it looks as if she cannot be saved. Queen Elsa returns and sees what has happened and hugs Princess Anna’s frozen statue. Since Queen Elsa loves her sister, Princess Anna thaws and is saved by an act of true love by her sister. This proves that an act of true love can come from anyone, not just a male figure.

I personally feel that Disney movies are good for children to watch because it is a break from reality for them to get lost in a different world where anything is possible. Children can be whatever they want and don’t let anyone or anything get in their way.

 

 

 

 

7 thoughts on “The Life of a Disney Child: Are Disney Movies Good or Bad for Children?

  1. Taylor,

    I completely agree with you! I have always thought that criticisms of Disney movies are completely wrong and over exaggerated. When I read your post, however, I started to consider this more. I loved how you pointed out several specific examples of Disney movies that could be portrayed in racist/sexist ways. Interpreting Beauty and the Beast as abusive was specifically interesting.

    Do you think that any of these perceptions of these Disney movies could possibly be true? From reading your article I am starting to reconsider my assumption that they are false. In order to expand on your topic, maybe look into the analyzing of DIsney movies. Who does the analyzing? Do these so called experts know what they are talking about? You could also find out more about the producers and writers of these movies and if they are known to be involved with anything of this sort.

    Overall, I loved your post. Super interesting!

    Elena

    • Hey Elena,

      After reading more articles I am starting to believe that these accusations are true. There seems to be a lot of evidence to support these assumptions.

      I have decided to change my research to the evolution of Disney movies. Starting from the beginning where the princess was simply just a damsel in distress to now where there are movies such as Frozen that show how women are independent and can save themselves.

      Thanks for the advice!

      ~Taylor

  2. Hi Taylor!

    Wow what a thorough blog post! I think you really are making the best of this blog. Though your post was long, I think each section you wrote was meaningful. As we discussed in our meeting, though, you might want to break your larger sections off into smaller sections to make your blog easier to read.

    I found SOOOOOO many articles in google news when I searched for the terms “disney princess” – you really ought to do a google news search with those key words as soon as possible because there are a ton of great sources out there for you to explore.

    One source that found is an article about a YouTube video featuring the princess from Frozen. In the video, she tells some other Disney princessess that they gave up too much of themselves in order to pursue their charming princes. Here’s the link to the srticle: http://www.policymic.com/articles/83505/frozen-s-elsa-exposes-what-s-wrong-with-disney-princesses-in-this-fantastic-song

    And another article from that same site lists the reasons why Frozen is the most progressive movie ever: http://www.policymic.com/articles/79455/7-moments-that-made-frozen-the-most-progressive-disney-movie-ever

    Hope these help!
    ~Christina K.

  3. Taylor you saved my English grade, I am eternally grateful for you. thanks for having an opinion. love you lots xxx

  4. Hi, I don’t fully agree. I’m doing a school project for school and when i read this i was deciding if this was true but this is just a misunderstanding.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *